G Scale Model Train Forum banner

Hot Loco Carriers

18K views 33 replies 19 participants last post by  Captain Dan  
Ed,

Thank you for taking the time to document your locomotive builds. I have thoroughly enjoyed following your progress at Flickr.com (search for edhume3). Your work is both inspirational and instructional and I just wanted to pass along my gratitude. Must confess I saw one of your hot locomotive carriers there and shamelessly copied the design...

Image


Cheers, Walt
 
Ed, Jerry and RJD,

Thanks for the kind words. I purchased the aluminum for this project on-line and it was a small order. They must have pulled the material from the "shorts" bin because the aluminum was in pretty rough shape. Ed makes metalworking look easy. Sometimes looks are deceiving.
Image
It took a bit of effort to make the carrier so I figured I may as well put forth the extra effort to make it look pretty. A quick once over with the random orbit sander and some 320 grit sandpaper, a few strokes with 0000 steel wool, a light application of Renaissance micro-crystalline wax and voilĂ ... it shines.

Image


At this point I have a carrier but nothing to carry.
Image
Little by little (read: as the budget allows) I have been collecting the parts, tools and information to kitbash a Roundhouse "Billy" chassis and boiler into a 7/8ths scale Hunslet. The folks over at 7-8ths.info have been very helpful in pointing me towards information on the English prototype for this locomotive. If all goes well, it will make its debut at the National Summer Steamup in July.

This is my first attempt at kitbashing and my first experience with metalworking/machining. I am quickly learning to appreciate the skill of a machinist! I've been a termite up to now and never really had to worry about cutter speed or depth of cut. "Fools go where angels fear to tread" is coming to mind for some reason.

Anyway, the build will hopefully be fun and doubtlessly be educational. Maybe in the end the thing will even run!!!
Image


Warm Regards,
Walt
 
Hi Greg,

...not a dumb question at all.

My little carrier is only 8" x 18". Size and weight are not really an issue.

I would estimate that Ed's carrier is about 32" long (please correct me Ed if I am wrong).
A 32" carrier can still be handled comfortably from the ends without feeling stretched.

The Accucraft Royal Hudson has a combined length (loco + tender) of 37". It is also heavy, hence the center handle on David's carrier.

I am probably the least qualified person to chime in here seeing as how I don't even have an engine yet but I would venture to say that securing the engine to the carrier is a more significant factor than carrier size.
If the engine is not secured well, it is going to be difficult to handle regardless of size.
If it is secured well, then even if the carrier tips, it doesn't result in disaster.

Your question is a valid one because sometimes it is hard to judge size from a photograph.

Walt