G Scale Model Train Forum banner

This one got away

367 views 8 replies 5 participants last post by  ferroequinologist  
#1 ·
I took a bucket-list trip to the UK to see the railways that I missed 50 years ago before I emigrated. (Photo essay coming soon.)
On my list was to stop at Ellis Clark Trains, which was 10 minutes from my friends home where we stayed. I was after a LNER D16 that they had advertised, and reserved for me.

Image


Unfortunately, they had screwed up the listing - they said it was butane fired. I was suspicious, noting the fittings on the tender:

Image


It was indeed alcohol fired. The price was very reasonable, and I have a set of Gresley teaks, so I am still sorely tempted to buy it and ask a friend to run it for me! But the temptation is wearing off and I don't need another LNER loco.
 
#3 ·
That loco looks really good Pete and personally I really like alcohol fired loco's, with the exhaust draft working like a real one to pull on the fire it makes running more engaging but then again gas is easy. If it's a two cylinder loco in good mechanical condition then that's another positive.
We all don't "need" another loco but a set of teaks with this at the head would be nice.
There is a mathematical equation as to how many locomotives we actually need' it is where X is always the correct number and A is the number of loco's we have now so it's A + 1 = X. Does help with your dilemma ?
 
#5 ·
Pete -- If I were you I'd buy it anyway. It's a gorgeous loco. And if you decide to later sell it on, surely there's someone in the Aikenback group who would jump at the chance to own it. Finally -- there's a lot to be said about alcohol firing. The loco is alive in a way that a gas-fired loco isn't. I really enjoy listening to the beat of the exhaust and the challenge of matching the throttle setting, the blower setting, and the load.
 
#7 ·
Pete -- If those wick burners are what I think they are, they're not all that terribly unusual. Air reaches the wicks the traditional way -- from the outside of the wick holder -- but in addition, air is delivered up through a hollow central cylinder. That way you get two surfaces of wick burning -- the inside and outside of the wick assembly so, if constructed properly, you get that much more heat output. Eddie Cooke, of 7mm live steam fame, designed a lot of locos with this inside/outside combustion model, and his locos steamed like witches. This loco is very enticing: clean as a whistle, sprung suspension, Eddie Cooke-style burners, gorgeous paint. I'm salivating...