G Scale Model Train Forum banner

1 - 20 of 20 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
291 Posts
Nice! And that will be very cool looking when it starts to mature! Trees, building ballast etc

Jason
 

·
Super Modulator
Joined
·
20,525 Posts
The sound file in the F3 sounds like a steam loco....


Very nice and I commend you on your sculpting and nice broad curves.


Greg
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
42 Posts
Discussion Starter #4
Thanks for the compliments!


2 things have changed since the post.



1.) I'm going to replace both 10' radius switches with #6 turnouts.

2.) I'm redoing the S curve grade, the one where the DRGW gondola behind the locos started to tip over, but survived. I'm going to lower the grade and widen the curves to ease my stress when running heavy trains up that hill. Can't wait till I show you the progress in another video!
 

·
Super Modulator
Joined
·
20,525 Posts
Good call on the #6 turnouts, whose are you going to use? They usually can stand some tweaking, be sure to run a track gauge through them, Aristo ones, for example tend to be tight in one direction.


Can you give the time x:xx in your video so I know which S curve you are talking about? Your curves look so broad I did not see a problem, but perhaps the grade is more than I can see, what is the grade there? (hint: get a small computerized level that reads in %)


Greg
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
42 Posts
Discussion Starter #6
Fixed the grade so here's another train ...

This S curve is a 3.5% ruling grade. I lowered the grade on the curves and raised the grade on the straight sections. I also made the curves a bit wider. One thing I learned, Aristocraft brass rail is really very soft. If you mistreat it, it will bend. Not so with LGB brass rail. So I used brand new Aristo 8' rails with LGB Flex Ties, and at the critical curve tied those to LGB 5' Flex Track with screw type joiners. It makes all the difference. The rails naturally will 'cant' in the right places and Aristo SD45s (which have the most finicky of diesel trucks IMO) won't derail. My USA Trains SD40 will take curves and questionable track very well, but it has such a wide swing on curves that its body mounted couplers will pull the first freight car off the rails. So I have to now widen a curve or two so I can run the SD40 as a trailing unit. Right now, it can only run as the lead unit.


 

·
Super Modulator
Joined
·
20,525 Posts
Yes, you are learning!


Had a heated discussion on another forum with a guy claiming that an SD40 would work on 4' diameter curves and was happy on 8'..... I told him put it on 8' and try coupling a car to the loco...



I told him he was crazy about 4' diameter curves with that loco.


He could not admit he was in error, but you are seeing the evidence of long locos and body mounts.


A hint, with a long loco, use a longer car behind it, it's overhang will more closely match the loco, so as wrong as it sounds, a 50 foot car with a body mount coupler behind the SD might be more successful than a 40 foot.



No truck mount couplers on the car behind the loco.


Greg
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
42 Posts
Discussion Starter #9
Good call on the #6 turnouts, whose are you going to use? They usually can stand some tweaking, be sure to run a track gauge through them, Aristo ones, for example tend to be tight in one direction.

Greg



Thanks Greg - you are right about those Aristo #6 turnouts. I've been seeing the cars jumping (not derailing tho) on the point rails. Investigating I've found the point rails are wider at the point on one side than the other, hence they squeeze flanges. Seems like the quality control at the factory wasn't up to snuff.



Looking for tips and tricks to fix these otherwise great switches.
 

·
Super Modulator
Joined
·
20,525 Posts
Aristo and quality control should not be in the same sentence ha ha!


Well priced, but often need something fixed/tweaked.


look on my site, several pages on fixing/improving the Aristo #6
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
42 Posts
Discussion Starter #11
O well ...

I should have known that something put off would inevitably not wait. No sooner than I planned not to pull up those #6 switches mentioned previously in this thread, than one switch's point rails lost its screw. It may have vibrated loose while grinding the point rails.



So I pulled up the switch and the others too. Might as well. Fortunately I found the screw. It has a spring between the head and the bottom of the switch. The other point rail's screw was loose too. Here's the screws I'm talking about:





The screwdrivers point to them. Both of the other turnouts also have loose screws. Again, could be lack of quality control at the factory, maybe my grinding loosened them. So I screwed them back sort of tight, not so much that they won't switch. I noticed that the back of the point rail, not the point, the other end, would wobble. Now they don't.


I also brought the flange rails closer to the stock rails - about .1" apart per TedD's recommendation. Now the trains mostly flow smoothly through the switches. The Aristo SD45's still sort of jolt, so I am looking into that. It looks like the SD45's 'like' a little bit wider than correct gauge width as they won't misbehave on parts of the switch where the gauge is wider than the parts where they jolt.


Also, the Aristo Wye's frog causes the SD45's to really jolt, even with the narrower flangeway that I fixed. I checked the gauge and its actually the correct gauge at the frog! One of the only places on the switch that is. So maybe I'll have to grind it wider.



All the other cars and locos (Aristo, LGB and USAT) work great without scaring me when they go through the switches now.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
42 Posts
Discussion Starter #13
Greg I love your site! One thing - it looks like my SD45 wheels are the old type - not "D". Their back to back spacing is part of my "jolting" thru the switches problem. Is there a way to get those stretched out? Also, can I grind those outsized flanges shorter like the "D"?
 

·
Super Modulator
Joined
·
20,525 Posts
Unfortunately, very few locos were produced with the "D" type wheels, only the last 2 runs of locos produced.


If you are handy (and I think you are!) you can get some brass shim stock and put between one wheel and the axle to correct the issue.


You have to cut it in a bit of a pie shape to accommodate the tapered axle.


The other way to fix takes total teardown of the gearboxes and shims between the metal half axles and the main worm gear... a lot of work and making the shims is no easy task.


Greg
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
42 Posts
Discussion Starter #15
I found the 'jolting' issue!


Followed this article's advice - https://www.elmassian.com/index.php...e-power/sd45/sd45-weights-and-railing-install


Down near the bottom of the article it describes the wheel problem. But my problem is not the wheels - it's the gearbox!


My locos are so old (the 2001 run) and I bought them like new, that the lubrication is practically fossilized. And, the gearboxes inside the truck are supposed to swivel side to side, up and down, but the lube had frozen them in place! Thus, when there is an inconsistency in the track, they acted like a 'centipede with a stiff neck'. (I love "Last of the Giants"):cool:


So I took off the bottom cover of the truck and sprayed a drop of PB Blaster on each side of the gearbox and worked them side to side, loosening them back to the original design. I did notice the front gearbox (towards the end of the loco) did not want to wobble as much as the other two, but it does move a bit now.



I ran the SD45s and the improvement is 100% - they do not derail anywhere and don't lift their wheels at all. Best of all, they don't 'jolt' going thru the turnouts!!!:D
 

·
Super Modulator
Joined
·
20,525 Posts
so, I'd like you to buy some specific loco lubricants, look for the combination pack from hob-e-lube ... use the heavy gear oil on the axles to keep them sliding side to side, lighter lube will not stay there and keep them moving.


As for the gearboxes rocking along the long axis, over the years Aristo changed the rubber pads between the gearbox and the gearboxes several time. No tried and true method, but you could take off the bottom cover and put a bit of light lube on the saddles where the gearboxes swivel..
;
https://elmassian.com/index.php/lar...p-tips/aristo-motive-power/prime-mover-basics


Note what happens if the axles are not lubed to promote side to side movement:
hopefully you read this page



Greg
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
42 Posts
Discussion Starter #17
Thanks again Greg.


Can you lube the axles from outside of the gearbox or does it have to be disassembled?
 

·
Super Modulator
Joined
·
20,525 Posts
Yes, just a drop of heavy gear oil on the exposed axle, work the axle side to side to work in.



This is a maintenance must... besides the issue you found, there is a club in Florida that regularly destroys their locos, those pictures are from their locos... there is a ball bearing that rides on the axle to pick up power, let it get dry and it grinds a groove in the axle, locking the axle from moving.


 

·
Registered
Joined
·
42 Posts
Discussion Starter #19
By heavy gear oil, you could be referring to 80W automotive diff oil possibly? Or is it one of the HobbyLubes?
 

·
Super Modulator
Joined
·
20,525 Posts
The hob-e-lube stuff seems to be "sticky" and stays in place.


I'd buy the tried and true stuff, yes you could save a few bucks using automotive stuff, but again this is not a great cost, you won't need to buy it again for years.


 
1 - 20 of 20 Posts
Top