G Scale Model Train Forum banner

Big Train Show 2012: Vendors Pt.1

9.3K views 21 replies 12 participants last post by  Pete Thornton  
Posted By Gary Woolard on 07 Jun 2012 12:27 AM


SWMTP snapped this as Cliff was explaining to me why their new T1 is an alcohol burner (I was complaining about it, frankly!) The logic starts with the prototype -- this beautiful Raymond Loewy skinned streamliner was the last steamer built for the Pennsylvania Railroad, which of course runs in the East. So it follows that the majority of this engine's fans are also on the east coast. (Maybe that's true? I just like the looks of the engine!)

And what do eastern live-steamers like to do? They like to run in the snow, the silly children!. And even us dyed-in-the-SPF30 west coastal steamers know that gas-fired engines, while generally a lot more convenient than alcohol beasties, do get a bit cranky in cold weather! And that's why Accucraft made the T1 an alcohol burner. (Maybe next time I'll ask Cliff how many strawberries fit in a 5-gallon can [abstruse reference])










If that is actually the logic for making the T1 an alcohol burner, they need to fire whoever did that research! :\

I have been an east-coast live steamer for 10 years now..im a member of a live steam club, and have been to a ton of steam ups..many of them very large.
I see very very very very few alcohol burners..alcohol burners are few and far between, and most of the alcohol burning locomotives I have seen were purchased because they were rare and unusual..I have always felt, and observed, that American live steam hobbyists overwhelmingly prefer butane burners, and alcohol is an obscure niche thing, perhaps more common in Europe..

That was definitely a bad choice by accucraft..most people in the T1's home range are very unfamiliar with alcohol burning..its very rare and unusual here in the North-east USA..

oh, and also, very very very few of us run live steam in the snow, or run in the winter at all..its extremely uncommon. In fact, in my 10 years in the live steam hobby, I have never once personally heard of anyone I know ever running live-steam in the snow..ever..you might see it here on MLS, or read about it SitG, but for the hobby at large, its very uncommon.


very weird to hear Accucraft to say that about us..nothing about that statement is even remotely accurate..
North-East live steam hobbyists who prefer alcohol burners, and commonly run in the winter, are maybe 1% of the hobby..probably less.


Scot