Posted By Greg Elmassian on 06/07/2009 7:03 PM
Chuck, as the thread has progressed, the focus and the discussion has likewise.
The original question is/was:
Thank you all for the informative n entertaining contributions on this great website. Linda n i have laid down about 250 ft of a stainless loop of track, ten ft curves, with about a hundred of it trestled, bridged, or riding atop a precarious ridge thru our mountan logging camp. we have a question about powering up our railroad, and would appriciate any n all advice/insight from you all.
we will be using a DCC system in the future, but would like to run some trains fairly soon.
IF we were to hook up something like MRC's "big handled "10amp PS/controller now. could we later use this unit for the power supply for a yet undetermined DCC system? If so, how?... and if not, what would work? Thanks! (we're too overwelmed with DCC info to make a decision right now)
So, is the MRC a good choice in this case? Yes I think so:
[*]not expensive [*]can be used to run trains now [*]can be used later to run DCC [/list] Now, the Bridgewerks has been documented (many posts in this and other forums) to SOMETIMES put out a very high voltage when lightly loaded. I have seen no posts that the MRC does this, and I have an MRC and mine does not do this.
Therefore I believe it is not the best choice for DCC, for exactly the reasons in my post you quoted.
Maybe "bad" is an inflammatory adjective, but if it was inexpensive and had the propensity to have overvoltage that would make it a poor choice. The fact that it is expensive and had this propensity and DCC is sensitive to overvoltage when you run near the "limit" as we usually need to in large scale DCC... then my OPINION is that it is a bad choice (for DCC).
No, the MRC is not regulated, but it is not expensive and does not have any reported overvoltage problems to my knowledge.
That's just about as logical and factual as I can be based on my research, reading forums and personal experience as explained above.
Regards, Greg
p.s. in the light of other recent threads, what I recommend for others is based on my best perception of their needs and priorities as they state it, which may be different than my needs and priorities.
Well Greg that's great that YOUR topic has moved on but I feel that your misleading folks with YOUR facts.
Earlier in this thread George posted " You will want about 22 to 24 volts of DCC on the track for mainline speeds, about 16 to 18 volts for NG speeds. This means that for mainline operation, you will want 26 to 28 volts of DC at 10 amps or better. Most DC power packs will not do this. For AC input, you will want 18 to 20 volts AC at 16 amps."
Greg your own post on page one agrees with George "That's one reason I keep recommending the MRC unit. I recommend 24 volts DC in for most DCC systems (that can take DC). I use 27 volts myself which get very close to 24 to the track (after the DCC booster), and gets about 21 to the motor itself"
Since MRC's own pulished documents rate the Power G at 22 VDC...here's the link..
MRC Power G
This FACT alone tells me that the Power G is not the best suited for this topics Author RioShay.
So let's move on tou YOUR next recommendation the switching regulated power supply the Meanwell S-320-24 which in my opinion isn't the best power supply for running trains in conventional track power mode. Why do I feel this way well maybe because of the phone conversations over the years with both USA Trains service & Phoenix sound customer service about using switching power supplies with their products..which is something they don't recommend by the way. What do they recommend?? Clean DC Power.
Not that I'm against switching power supplies as they do have a place in large scale but to me it's not operating trains in conventional track powered mode but ONLY powering a DCC equipped layout. How do I know this well because that's how my layout was powered when I used DCC.
Have you ever seen a USA Hudson trying to operate on a track powered switching power supplied layout especially when it's just sitting with enough volts to operate the sound, lights & smoke unit?? All it'll do is flicker the lights!!
Now as far as Bridgewerks being way over priced and out of reach for anybody but the well to do let's just take a look. A 10 amp MRG Power G lists for $269.98 but can be bought at Wholesale trains for $154.99 which is rated at only 22 volts.
On the other hand a Bridgewerks 10 amp Magnum 10-SR lists for $379.99 but can be bought at Ridge Road Station for $273.59 which will deliver at least 28 volts.
So for what?? $120.00 more you get 25% more available power to the rails. Clean power that ALL trains like.
Greg, Have you ever tried powering a DCC system with a Bridgewerks or have you ever owned a Bridgewerks power supply? Do you have any FACTS such as charts, graphs ar maybe a scope shot of a Bridgewerks showing the fabled unloaded legendary voltage spikes?? Or is all your FACTS just heresay jotted down in cyberspace??
Something else about Bridgewerks & Ruby's Resturant. Ruby's has large scale trains operating and when they were powered with a switching power supply the motors were burning out in a few weeks. Since using a Bridgewerks the motors last a year!! How do I know this because I sold a Bridgewerks Power Supply to the fellow who has the contracts to keep them operating on Ebay a few years back.
Greg, Why don't you just give the owner of Bridgewerks Dave Sauerwald a call at 800-908-9997 and discuss the lengendary voltage spike. By the way Dave is an electrical engineer and his son is Director of Engineering at National Semi Conductor out in Santa Clara.