G Scale Model Train Forum banner
101 - 116 of 116 Posts
Cliffy said I should post this here.

This is what I did for a stub switch.

I put in a expansion track from Split Jaw.

This allows the piviot track to move with out the ends of the rails changing length

It also allows me to retract the pivot track from the stationary ones.

I still have to work on how to move the pivot track from one section to another

Not all the stationary ones have been cut to length in the pictures.

When finished they will all be the same length
 

Attachments

Picking nits...
I'd call it a 5 way selector switch, but not a true stub as he has no froggies .
Carry on.
John
 
I put in a expansion track from Split Jaw.

This allows the piviot track to move with out the ends of the rails changing length
Neat solution JJ.

I still have to work on how to move the pivot track from one section to another
Your hand might work well!
Otherwise, my hardware store has 12" and 24" lengths of threaded rod. Lay it under the ends of the tracks, attach the moving stub with a nut or two, and turn it with a knob, handle, motor ?

I've seen folk use gate bolt-style latches to hold the rails aligned.

Image
 
Hey Pete

I have used those bolt style latches They work real well for two position switches.

I have some on my layout now.

I have a search on E Bay now for Jack Screws. I have a driver board for a stepper motor too.


JJ
 
yah dats why I said what I did.
I'm curious tho why you suggested cluttering up Amber's thread?
I don't think JJ's creation really belongs here, a totally different breed and it's not a fine scale effort. Nothing wrong with his creation, but here?
What do I know? I'm just an old geezer....

Happy Rails

John
 
yah dats why I said what I did.
I'm curious tho why you suggested cluttering up Amber's thread?
I don't think JJ's creation really belongs here, a totally different breed and it's not a fine scale effort. Nothing wrong with his creation, but here?
What do I know? I'm just an old geezer....

Happy Rails

John

I put it here because of the expansion track. I thought that part was relevant.

JJ
 
Sorry JJ, I wasn't casting aspersions, no disrespect to you. I remember you said Cliffy suggested it...
It looks like your trick is handy, but not relevant to a scale model. There is no need for an expansion in any other switch.
That was my point and I'm curious why Cliffy thought it is. Ok they are both ways to change track.... similarity ends... to me.
I think the expansion use is good enough to be a stand alone thread.
It's no big deal.
John
 
Though the design of stub and "yard" (or whatever) switches is different, I consider them to be similar in regards to bending the common rails to one of two or more positions to accomplish the switching. True, "stubs" have frogs, but it seems to me that the need for such is a function of angular separation of the outbound legs, rather than anything fundamental.
 
Discussion starter · #116 ·
I haven't been able to get anything more done on that stub switch for the past month or 2, just too many other distractions. All I really need to do now is to put the tie bar onto the stub rails so that I can move them with a switch stand of some kind, and then build a switch stand for it. You'd think I could get that done, but it hasn't happened yet. Who knows, maybe this coming week when I'm not at work...
 
101 - 116 of 116 Posts