G Scale Model Train Forum banner
1 - 20 of 48 Posts
Pete, I doubt it, if you read the features "document" you will see they are different.

1. length 33.5" (makes them scale 80', Aristo are 72')
2. die cast "cushioned" coupler (like the streamliners)
3. rubber diaphragms (Aristo were hard plastic)
4. coupler lift bar, air hoses
5. lighted drum head on observation car, illuminated markers, and METAL railings
6. die cast metal trucks
7. fold down vestibule step

Those particular features convince me that these are all new.

Greg 1,220
 
Sadly way out of reach price wise for most consumers, was really hoping for something new at about half the price they are asking for these.
Half? even that is crazy-expensive for the majority of G-scalers im sure..
more like 10% for me, before we even approach reality.

Image


Scot
 
Half? even that is crazy-expensive for the majority of G-scalers im sure..
more like 10% for me, before we even approach reality.

Scot
I hear ya! But I knew what ever they were going to produce it was going to be die cast and in the prestige series. Was just hoping it would be somewhat in reach so I could get something new from them, guess I will keep waiting.
 
Scot, $370 for a die cast northern?

$1200 list on Bachman NG plastic locos..

Aristo Craft was never that cheap LIST price.

The heavyweights are a reasonable price, will be buying a complete set, even though my Aristo heavyweights are 72' long, still have always wanted the full 80 footers.

My Aristo set will be going up for sale now.

Greg 1,219
 
Scot, $370 for a die cast northern?
I didnt mean $370 for a die cast Northern specifically..
sure, a die cast Northern is going to be multi-thousands of dollars..no problem.
I just meant $370 in general, for any locomotive, diesel, steam, whatever, before i'm a buyer.
and even that is still high..im more of a $250 buyer. ;)
but to each their own..

Scot
 
sure, a die cast Northern is going to be multi-thousands of dollars..no problem.
I wonder if this is another USA Trains list vs dealer price. The streamline coaches are $499 on USATrains.com, but $299 at Charles Ro. The SD70MAC is $729 list but $434 at Charles Ro. On that basis, the Northern should list for about $2,250. That seems reasonable, as the Hudson was $1995.

The flaw in that argument is that the flyer lists the heavyweight coaches for $299, which is about where the streamliners sit. Can't believe they will sell at Charles Ro for $176 !!
 
OK, Scot, I get that you want to buy a locomotive for $350 or $250... good for you.

Having that expectation of a model of this quality (based on the USAT Hudson and Big Boy) is not realistic, so you will never buy a locomotive like this. In fact you won't buy much of anything new, right? No offense, I just don't see why you would even post something like that. Are you mad at the industry?

On the other hand, yes, this is an expensive loco, a plastic one of lesser quality though would still be most likely around $1,400 list, comparing it to Bachmann and the last list price of the last Aristo steamer, the Consolidation.

My guess is that the street price will be lower, but this will never be an inexpensive loco.

Pete: I surely hope that the street price of the Northern comes down in the low two thousand land... but, owing to the scarcity, and the, well, coolness, I will most likely buy one no matter what.

And yes, I'll probably sell my Aristo heavyweight fleet now, since there is NO alternative now... I would suspect they will be worth less when the USAT ones get into stock... remember buy low, sell high!

Greg
 
Thanks for posting this announcement. I used to get the USA Trains emails. I guess I need to re-subscribe. I'm looking forward to getting a set of the SP Heavyweights in Pullman Green. I've never been disappointed with USA Trains products (I just wish they'd ditch 1:29 for 1:32). I've never been a fan of Aristocraft. The quality of their stuff seemed to range from mediocre to downright poor. No Aristocraft product ever made it into my fleet without some time on the bench first. Even if all the used Aristo heavyweights drop in price, they're not worth my time.
 
So you won't be buying my used Aristo HWs? :(

To be fair, I don't think I have ANYTHING large scale that did not need some tweaking.

Yep, I definitely have more pages on how to correct stuff in Aristo than for USAT.

Greg
 
1 - 20 of 48 Posts