Wednesday, June 19, 2013  | Forums
Which power units would you recommend.
Last Post 24 Jan 2010 09:24 AM by Peter Osborne. 10 Replies.
AddThis - Bookmarking and Sharing Button Printer Friendly
Sort:
PrevPrev NextNext
You are not authorized to post a reply.
Author Messages
just startingUser is Offline
Passenger
Passenger
Send Message
Posts:4
just starting

--
22 Jan 2010 09:58 AM  
Hi to Forum Readers,
 
I am just getting started with  a Garden Railway. Fortunatly and unfortunatly  while visiting a friend  in Canada I gave up smoking after 50 years of it and thought if I bought something I could do for a hobby it would keep my hands busy. My friends took me to a garden centre, there on show was An Aristocraft Pacific locomotive with 6 heavywieght coaches to match. It must be something in the blood that attracted me to them ,my grandfather was a blacksmith on the LMS Loco Works and my own father was a railway coach body builder and I just love steam engines and lantern roof railway carrages.
I asked the guy in the store "Is that what they call G scale?" it was hardly a question but the guy rubbed his hands together and sold me the lot, I paid the man for the goods and  the shipping to UK. I walked out  the store some dollars lighter with a few rail magazines under my arm. After an hours of reading I relized my knowledge of model railways was zero and  1-29 scale  probably was not the best choice as figures and road vehicles and buildings were short on the ground. After I got it home  the store brought out a baggae car I thought I had better have the full set so it has also traveled a long way from China to Canada to UK. Clearly there is no turning back.  I now need to purchase besides more track some sort of power and control, as we live in a very wet part of the world where it rains a lot, I thought Radio Control and Battery Power would be the answer although all the carrage lights would require rewiring, I may prefer to do this than clean yards of track each time it is operated, so the question is , am I going down the right road and should I purchase the Aristocraft Battery Box Car and  will this give the engine enough power to pull 8 carrages or should I do something else or do I power up the lines, and with what bearing in mind many of the secound hand track I keep buying up at a reasonable price off e-bay will require a lot of cleaning. I am sure there are aguements on fores and against but all recomendations on tried and tested equipment  will be very  welcome from those who are experienced. 
 
Many Thanks 
Just Starting
Derbyshire England 
lownoteUser is Offline
Conductor
Conductor
Send Message
Posts:3142
lownote

--
22 Jan 2010 10:24 AM  
Congratulations!

I can't help you with battery--Track power is the way I go. It works very well for me with very few headaches, and the lights in coaches is a major reason why--we like to run a lot at dusk and enjoy the effect of the lights. Eventually, if you run on track power, you want to clamp all the joints with rail-clamps. But when you start, just swab some anti-corrosion paste in the joints and slip the track together. I live in a mixed climate with lots of rain, occasional heavy snow and summer temps in the 90s. I run a track cleaning car a few times around at every session, but other than that I really don't have to do much to the track--the "problem" of dirty track seems to me to be highly overrated. Other people have a harder time with it. Battery operation never appealed to me, other swear by it and the subject of track vs battery tends to raise hackles.

If you have used track, just clean the top with acetone, or laquer thinner. Maybe clean the joints too. The track doesn't have to be shiny to conduct well.

Check those coaches--are the lights LEDs, or incandescent bulbs? If they are LEDS you should see a lot of small lights--maybe 20? I never counted. if they are incandescent there should far fewer, maybe 8. Incandescents draw a lot more current, which is a big issue with battery
Evading the Midas touch of expertise


http://chnm.gmu.edu/courses/magic/westover/
Greg ElmassianUser is Offline
1st Class Member
Engineer
Engineer
Send Message
Posts:15087
Greg Elmassian

--
22 Jan 2010 10:50 AM  
First, battery or track power, there will still be SOME cleaning of track, otherwise you will have derailments.

It's true that track power will require "cleaner" rail, and it's most operative to say that if you use brass rail for track power, you will need to remove the oxidation from it. How often? It depends, some people need to do it every 2 days, some people once a year, it's a gamble there. If you use stainless steel rail, then you have as much track cleaning either way, battery or track power, you still will need to remove large leaves, twigs, etc.

There's lots of pro's and cons, but let me give you a monetary "division point": If you run a battery car and share it with all your locos, then cheapest way to go, and least maintenance is this way.

If you want a battery per loco, or run multiple locos, and want some type of independent control, at about 4-6 locos, is the decision point.... fewer, battery is less expensive, more, track power is less expensive... and you can be talking 100-200 dollars of "difference" per loco.

It's always a tough decision.

By the way, rain keeps track clean... it's air pollutants and dust and grit that cause you to "clean" rail, i.e. remove oxidation... again, SS rail eliminates that problem.

I suggest you decide how you will EVENTUALLY have your layout, how many locos, how many running at one time, do you want smoke? lighted cars? ... if you think for the future and make a decision based on that, you will do well.

Regards, Greg

Be sure to visit my site, lots of technical tips and modifications, and you can search for topics and key words.

 

 Click here for Greg's web site

Note: After 15,000 posts, the answer is probably already here on mls, and I have participated. If I just post a thumbs up, email me privately if you have questions that are unanswered on the thread, I'm tired of the acrimony.

 
PLEASE NOTE: I have disabled Private Messaging, please use regular email: greg@elmassian.com
TorbyUser is Offline
1st Class Member
Conductor
Conductor
Send Message
Posts:4738
Torby

--
22 Jan 2010 03:50 PM  
Welcome to the obsession. Congratulations on picking up a Pacific and Heavyweights.

Yea, just forget putting power on the track. Don't worry about the lights in the coaches till you're ready to put batteries and LED's in the coaches. Now you don't have to worry about wires, track conductivity or continuity. Just makes things easier.

Of course, I did once go to a train show with my loco, tender, freight cars, caboose, but not my box of batteries and chargers. Can you spell "ADD?" Of course, if I hadn't rewired the loco so extensively, I could have just thrown the track/battery switch and run anyhow.
Electronic junk you never knew you needed: http://www.barefootelectronics.com
just startingUser is Offline
Passenger
Passenger
Send Message
Posts:4
just starting

--
22 Jan 2010 03:52 PM  
Thanks Guys,
You have talked me back into useing track power.
Thanks for the tips on cleaning the rails and clamping.
Now to find a good transformer and controler over here and read up on wiring up.
 
Much Obliged 
 
Roger just starting 
Greg ElmassianUser is Offline
1st Class Member
Engineer
Engineer
Send Message
Posts:15087
Greg Elmassian

--
22 Jan 2010 04:30 PM  
If you will be a while on straight DC, then I recommend the MRC power G, 10 amps, sturdy construction, purchased by many, and not expensive.

Regards, Greg

Be sure to visit my site, lots of technical tips and modifications, and you can search for topics and key words.

 

 Click here for Greg's web site

Note: After 15,000 posts, the answer is probably already here on mls, and I have participated. If I just post a thumbs up, email me privately if you have questions that are unanswered on the thread, I'm tired of the acrimony.

 
PLEASE NOTE: I have disabled Private Messaging, please use regular email: greg@elmassian.com
TonyWalshamUser is Offline
1st Class Member
Foreman
Foreman
Send Message
Posts:2185
TonyWalsham

--
22 Jan 2010 05:31 PM  
The MRC Power G is not sold in the UK. 240 volts and all that.
  Best wishes,
  Tony Walsham
 
  Remote Control Systems.  www.rcs-rc.com/
 
Modern technology. Old Fashioned reliability
JPCaputoUser is Offline
Passenger
Passenger
Send Message
Posts:149
JPCaputo

--
22 Jan 2010 05:58 PM  
I built a couple of my own. 1 with a large transformer, & bridge rectifier, then a variable voltage circuit with large output transistor. The other with a switching power supply, and the same output.

It is also possible to hotwire a couple old computer power supplies in series to get 24V, then add the variable power supply output. The older AT power supplies with hard switch on the AC line are easier to get running.

I have pics of 1 i made that has an automatic reverser built into it. It is a thread with the aristo reversing unit help.
aceinsppUser is Offline
1st Class Member
Engineer
Engineer
Send Message
Posts:5211
aceinspp

--
22 Jan 2010 07:21 PM  
Seeing how you live in another country some suggestions here would not work for you.  So it comes down as to what is available in a 10amp supply in your neck of the woods and then look for the best price.  That's if you still are looking at track power.  Later RJD
RJD Chief Engr D & S RR SA# 2510 and the 200th member
Greg ElmassianUser is Offline
1st Class Member
Engineer
Engineer
Send Message
Posts:15087
Greg Elmassian

--
22 Jan 2010 08:42 PM  
oops.. derbyshire....

Greg

Be sure to visit my site, lots of technical tips and modifications, and you can search for topics and key words.

 

 Click here for Greg's web site

Note: After 15,000 posts, the answer is probably already here on mls, and I have participated. If I just post a thumbs up, email me privately if you have questions that are unanswered on the thread, I'm tired of the acrimony.

 
PLEASE NOTE: I have disabled Private Messaging, please use regular email: greg@elmassian.com
Peter OsborneUser is Offline
Passenger
Passenger
Send Message
Posts:95
Peter Osborne

--
24 Jan 2010 09:24 AM  
If you're going track with DC, then you can't go wrong with the Aristo Train Engineer setup and the Elite (5 or 10amp) power supply. The ablity to follow your trains with a wireless remote is essential in Garden Railways, whatever your source of power is.

Good luck.

Peter.
You are not authorized to post a reply.

Active Forums 4.2
Top of Page | Terms of Use | Copyright 2009 by myLargescale.com/Model Railroads Online, LLC  | Privacy | Contact Us