Friday, February 03, 2012  | Forums
Model-T Railtruck Builder's Log
Last Post 24 Aug 2008 06:07 PM by Jerry Barnes. 87 Replies.
AddThis - Bookmarking and Sharing Button Printer Friendly
Sort:
PrevPrev NextNext
You are not authorized to post a reply.
Page 1 of 41234 > >>
Author Messages
maculsayUser is Offline
1st Class Member
Brakeman
Brakeman
Send Message
Posts:320
maculsay

--
04 May 2008 01:12 AM  
I was recently inspired by the live steam railtruck that was built by Sonny Wizelman and which competed in the 2008 drawbar contest at Diamondhead...and won it's division, I might add.

I started looking for 1:20.3-scale plans for an early 1900's Model-T truck as the basis for my scratchbuild. In the August 2004 issue of Garden Railway Magazine, a Ted Stinson plan set was included for a 1927 Model-T Oil Truck and will be serving as my underlying design for the Model-T Railtruck. This scaled drawing is available from Sidestreet Bannerworks. I also found that Northeast Narrow Gauge (nemodel.com) makes model kits in its Tin Lizzy line that has some of the more difficult parts, such as, radiator, steering wheel and headlight castings for the 1927 Model-T.



Although I was able to find documentation that Model-Ts were used as Rail vehicles, what I want to do won't be prototypical. I want to power it with a propane-fired boiler and steam-motor. But I want to stay close to the Model-T dimensions. The trick was going to be finding live steam components that'll stay within the dimensions of the Model-T vehicle. My initial searches didn't turn up any candidates until the last weekend's steamup, where Sonny gratiously brought his railtruck. It was obvious that staying within the confines of a 1927 Model-T truck was going to be difficult , if not impossible without making major extensions to the truck bed. But, lo-and-behold, Sonny's next live steam project required a small steam motor, boiler, and propane tank. Sonny had acquired the steam components for a "Pepper" locomotive but had since decided on a different solution and was about to return this little German made steam motor to Lutz Hielscher at www.hielscher-dampfmodelle.de. Size-wise, it looked to be just what I was looking for, so we made a deal. I now have a small steam motor, boiler, and propane tank hat will fit very nicely into the Model-T truck design requiring only about 3/4" overall extension to the length of the truck.


Steam motor/Boiler/Fuel tank dimensions/specs:

Overal motor size: 2" tall x 1" x 1/2".
This wobbler engine is geared 40:1 to the main drive axle thru an integrated gear train.
The flywheel is 1/2" in diameter.
Piston diameter is 3mm.
Stroke is 5mm.
The final drive (integrated axle) is 2.5mm in diameter.



The single-flue boiler is 35mm in diameter & 56mm tall.
The chimney is 26mm tall x 12mm in diameter.
The boiler water capacity is about 30ml.
Steam outlet pipe w/feed-thru lubricator is .080" diameter.
The burner is an external blow-torch type aimed at the L-shaped flue.



The butane fuel tank is plastic 2 3/8" long x 1 1/8" x 7/8".
w/built-in needle valve and on/off lever.


Here are the steam components assembled.


The initial "will it all fit" drawing shows the placement of the all essential running gear.


The initial testing I did was to see how the burner performed. Like most needle valves, it has a very small range between all-on or all-off.


The basic frame will be made from .032" thick brass plate and 5/16" square oak truck bed beams. The drive
wheels (rear) will have external ball bearing journals to minimize friction. The front wheels will also have ball bearings, but the journals will be on the inside of the frame.


Once I get the frame made and the steam components mounted, I will test to see how much weight this little beast will
hustle down the track. According to Lutz, this steam motor and it's gearing should have no trouble.

Any and all feedback will be appreciated.
Howard Maculsay SA #4450 My RailRoadRadio.net broadcast site
Jerry BarnesUser is Offline
1st Class Member
Conductor
Conductor
Send Message
Posts:3381
Jerry Barnes

--
04 May 2008 08:49 AM  
Neat idea, look forward to the story. Might submit it to Steam in the Garden, Ron is always looking for articles. No pay for them, but you don't get paid here either! Jerry
 Click here to visit my web site

 PLEASE NOTE: I have disabled private messages. Please use regular email juking (at) atcjet.net
steamboatmodelUser is Offline
Passenger
Passenger
Send Message
Posts:106
steamboatmodel

--
05 May 2008 06:42 AM  
Fantastic idea! How long does the motor run on a tank of fuel?
Regards,
Gerald
maculsayUser is Offline
1st Class Member
Brakeman
Brakeman
Send Message
Posts:320
maculsay

--
05 May 2008 10:53 PM  
Posted By steamboatmodel on 05/05/2008 6:42 AM
Fantastic idea! How long does the motor run on a tank of fuel?
Regards,
Gerald

Gerald...
I haven't tried testing run time yet, but the literature says about 15 minutes of run time can be expected. As soon as I get the undercarriage built, I'll give it a time test. I'm still looking for micro-miniature ball bearings (2.5mm inside diameter)for my journals...hopefully that'll help squeeze more run time by introducing a minimum of axle friction.
Howard Maculsay SA #4450 My RailRoadRadio.net broadcast site
maculsayUser is Offline
1st Class Member
Brakeman
Brakeman
Send Message
Posts:320
maculsay

--
05 May 2008 10:55 PM  
Posted By Jerry Barnes on 05/04/2008 8:49 AM
Neat idea, look forward to the story. Might submit it to Steam in the Garden, Ron is always looking for articles. No pay for them, but you don't get paid here either! Jerry

Jerry....that's a great idea...I might just do that. Thanks<img src=" border=0>
Howard Maculsay SA #4450 My RailRoadRadio.net broadcast site
HMeinholdUser is Offline
Brakeman
Brakeman
Send Message
Posts:493
HMeinhold

--
06 May 2008 08:20 AM  
Posted By maculsay on 05/05/2008 10:53 PM
I'm still looking for micro-miniature ball bearings (2.5mm inside diameter)for my journals...hopefully that'll help squeeze more run time by introducing a minimum of axle friction.



Howard,
try http://www.bocabearings.com/main1.a...rchbearing
I got my bearings for "Betsy" from them.
Regards
Henner
Donkey Doctor East Devils Hill Lumber Co.
maculsayUser is Offline
1st Class Member
Brakeman
Brakeman
Send Message
Posts:320
maculsay

--
06 May 2008 10:19 AM  
Posted By HMeinhold on 05/06/2008 8:20 AM
Posted By maculsay on 05/05/2008 10:53 PM
Howard,
try http://www.bocabearings.com/main1.a...rchbearing
I got my bearings for "Betsy" from them.
Regards




Henner....that's what I did, thank you.....but I ordered via their online website.:D
Howard Maculsay SA #4450 My RailRoadRadio.net broadcast site
normanUser is Offline
Brakeman
Brakeman
Send Message
Posts:210
norman

--
06 May 2008 10:24 PM  
Hi There:

Here is a factory model of a Stanley steamer automobile. I don't know what the wheel gauge is. The mechanical components may be usefull for your project.

http://www.ministeam.com/acatalog/H...scher.html

Norman

maculsayUser is Offline
1st Class Member
Brakeman
Brakeman
Send Message
Posts:320
maculsay

--
06 May 2008 11:01 PM  
Posted By norman on 05/06/2008 10:24 PM
Hi There:
Here is a factory model of a Stanley steamer automobile. I don't know what the wheel gauge is. The mechanical components may be usefull for your project.
http://www.ministeam.com/acatalog/H...scher.html
Norman




Thanks Norman....the steam engine/boiler/burner/tank I'm using all came from Lutz Hielscher at www.hielscher-dampfmodelle.de. Apparently www.mimisteam sells his stuff stateside.

Of course, I'm not going to have to convert automobile running gear to run on the tracks, so I don't have to mess with steering, etc. The hardest part I have is designing and making the wheels/journals and undercarriage. The cab and hood should be pretty easy.

Again Norman, thanks for putting me onto another Hielscher product source.
Howard Maculsay SA #4450 My RailRoadRadio.net broadcast site
maculsayUser is Offline
1st Class Member
Brakeman
Brakeman
Send Message
Posts:320
maculsay

--
07 May 2008 12:01 AM  
I have worked out some of the detail planning for making the undercarriage, which includes Front Pivot Bolster,
Journals & Wheels, Rear Journals & Wheels, the brass Frame and the hardwood truck bed supports.
I've located the miniature ball bearings from www.bocabearings.com and have them on order (they actually
shipped today). Also ordered the 2.5mm & 6mm drill & reamer for making a snug home for the bearings in my
journals and for drilling the wheel hubs for the 2.5mm axles.

Anyway, here's my working drawings, so far.





Still have to do some adjustment to the brass frame drawing once I receive the radiator casting.

Since I'll be using modified "Ozark Miniatures" fully sprung Journals, part#1010, with an axle that is integrated
directly with the gear train and steam cylinder, I will have to mount the little engine in a way to handle the range of movement allowed by the sprung journals.

Now I need to find a source for 4 of the 10 or 12-spoke wheels...outside flange diameter is 1.563" If someone
knows of a source for machined wheels, I'd appreciate getting a contact.....but if I have to machine them myself,
then so-be-it. It's just that I'm in the process of machining 16 wheel castings for my Class A Climax project and I'm sick of wheels right now.:sick:

More later!!
Howard Maculsay SA #4450 My RailRoadRadio.net broadcast site
maculsayUser is Offline
1st Class Member
Brakeman
Brakeman
Send Message
Posts:320
maculsay

--
24 May 2008 01:47 AM  
I received my bearings from Boca Bearings....boy are they little ones 2.5mm x 6mm. The
Tin Lizzy kit arrived from NENG, so I'll be using the radiator, headlights and
steering wheel castings. I got some wheel castings from Diana and Tom at
Sulphur Springs. They aren't quite the size I wanted, but I'll be able to machine
them to close to the size I want. They are cast iron.....my first attempt at
machining this stuff... any tips will be appreciated!!

I made the frame from .032" thick brass sheet and will attach the 2 Oak deck
beams (5" x 21/64" x 1/2") using hex head screws. The truck's bed decking and
cab floor will be 1/8" thick mahogany plywood scribed to represent individual planking.
The initial mockups of the truck's cab and hood/radiator was done and redone to get a fit. Particular attention was paid to the clearances needed for the butane tank & burner, since they will have to fit under the hood and pass thru the cab. The cab and hood/radiator will be made as a single removeable (lift-off) assembly. This should allow for easier refueling The cab will be made of .015" thick brass sheet.

I've decided to give a try at making a working hinged hood, like the real Tin-Lizzies. Here's my first attempt at a practice hinge. It'll take 3 hinges. Also shown is the radiator casting.

The hood pattern shows the placement of the 3 hinges. 1/16" brass wire will be soldered to the end-most edges of the hood. The upside-down Us are the front and rear hood supports. They are 1/8" brass U-channel into which the hood's soldered end wire will fit when closed.




I'll be using real glass (microscope slides) for the front windscreen. The lower half will be fixed, while the top half will swing out on a brass pivot at each end of the top edge.
Once I get the wheels machined and know the dimensions, I can finalize the design for the journals and I can machine them.
More later!!
Howard Maculsay SA #4450 My RailRoadRadio.net broadcast site
SteveCUser is Online
Moderator
Conductor
Conductor
Send Message
Posts:3864
SteveC

--
24 May 2008 02:11 AM  
Hey Howard,

Have you ever run across the following article, take a look at how Marc made his wheels...

Tin Lizzy
By Marc Horovitz
placitassteamUser is Offline
1st Class Member
Brakeman
Brakeman
Send Message
Posts:400
placitassteam

--
24 May 2008 09:43 PM  
Howard, Looking good, I really like the idea of a steam powered truck. I was looking at your front axle design, does it swivel? If so how is it steered? With only 4 wheels and a very short wheel base I think it would work fine with a fixed axle. My little rail truck has two fixed axles and has no trouble with curves.
Winn Erdman Steamaholic 291

maculsayUser is Offline
1st Class Member
Brakeman
Brakeman
Send Message
Posts:320
maculsay

--
25 May 2008 12:53 AM  
Posted By placitassteam on 05/24/2008 9:43 PM
Howard, Looking good, I really like the idea of a steam powered truck. I was looking at your front axle design, does it swivel? If so how is it steered? With only 4 wheels and a very short wheel base I think it would work fine with a fixed axle. My little rail truck has two fixed axles and has no trouble with curves.



Thanks Winn, for the inputs.
Interesting that you should ask about the steering:) As you can see I've designed-in axle bearings.....the idea being to reduce as much friction as possible since the steam motor is low powered. A swiveled bolster was to also help reduce drag in a turn, but I hadn't thought too much about fixed axle drag. Thinking more about the need for steering I'd recently had moved the bolsters pivot point forward of the axle and added a swingarm in order to add a centering spring.

I'm still considering making a separate axle for each front wheel to even cut down friction a bit more. This may be way beyond what is needed, but I do some of these things just to see if I can do it:crazy:
Howard Maculsay SA #4450 My RailRoadRadio.net broadcast site
maculsayUser is Offline
1st Class Member
Brakeman
Brakeman
Send Message
Posts:320
maculsay

--
25 May 2008 12:56 AM  
Posted By SteveC on 05/24/2008 2:11 AM
Hey Howard,

Have you ever run across the following article, take a look at how Marc made his wheels...

Tin Lizzy
By Marc Horovitz

Steve...I had seen this article awhile back but had forgotten about it....thanks for the reminder and the link.
Howard Maculsay SA #4450 My RailRoadRadio.net broadcast site
xo18thfaUser is Offline
1st Class Member
Foreman
Foreman
Send Message
Posts:1627
xo18thfa

--
25 May 2008 08:17 PM  
Hi Howard: That looks like a fun little project. And a nice job on it to boot.

Those cast iron wheels should turn fairly easily. If they are the same quality as a Stuart-Turner engine kit, they will turn like a dream. Turn cast iron at a much slower speed than other metals. The first cut is very critical. Run the lathe at the slowest speed and take a somewhat deep cut. You are trying to get under the outer scale of the casting on the first pass. Once you are into clean metal, the rest of the process is pretty much as you did on the bronze wheels for your Climax.

Once in a great while cast iron develops a hard spot. It is called "chill". Chilling happens when the iron cools too quickly in the mold. Chilled spots are impossible to machine. Ask to casting supplier for a replacement.

Looking good, Bob
Bob Sorenson
Las Vegas, Nevada
SA #13
"Goals are dreams with deadlines"
gibs035User is Offline
1st Class Member
Brakeman
Brakeman
Send Message
Posts:954
gibs035

--
26 May 2008 04:57 PM  
I understand someone had and Accucraft "Goose" at DiamondHead that had been converted to live steam.
Do you know what Live steam engine they used and would the little "PEPPER" engine work.
Just looking for someway to use the "GOOSE" since I have trouble getting the "Sparkie" pickups to work.
maculsayUser is Offline
1st Class Member
Brakeman
Brakeman
Send Message
Posts:320
maculsay

--
26 May 2008 10:05 PM  
Thanks Bobs...your comments are always appreciated. I read somewhere that the first...break-thru-the-outer-scale-cut...should be with a carbide tipped cutter. After that, HSS cutters are sufficient to finish the task. We'll see how it goes real soon.
Howard Maculsay SA #4450 My RailRoadRadio.net broadcast site
maculsayUser is Offline
1st Class Member
Brakeman
Brakeman
Send Message
Posts:320
maculsay

--
26 May 2008 10:53 PM  
Posted By gibs035 on 05/26/2008 4:57 PM
I understand someone had and Accucraft "Goose" at DiamondHead that had been converted to live steam.
Do you know what Live steam engine they used and would the little "PEPPER" engine work.
Just looking for someway to use the "GOOSE" since I have trouble getting the "Sparkie" pickups to work.

I wasn't at Diamondhead, but the rail truck that got me started on my Model-T rail truck was at Diamondhead. It's sorta resembles a "Goose", but isn't. Sonny Wizelman, the builder, used a Graham Industries http://www.grahamind.com/hm1.html HM1 Horizontal steam engine kit and a Heritage vertical boiler converted to butane.
As for using the "Pepper" steam motor, I'm not to sure if it's strong enough to propel it down the track, since the Goose locomotives all appear to be larger and heavier than what I'm building. My Model-T Railtruck is just 10 inches long.
Another problem converting a Goose to live steam would be the plastic material it's made from....that won't mix well with the burners heat.
Howard Maculsay SA #4450 My RailRoadRadio.net broadcast site
steamboatmodelUser is Offline
Passenger
Passenger
Send Message
Posts:106
steamboatmodel

--
27 May 2008 06:07 AM  
Posted By maculsay on 05/26/2008 10:05 PM
Thanks Bobs...your comments are always appreciated. I read somewhere that the first...break-thru-the-outer-scale-cut...should be with a carbide tipped cutter. After that, HSS cutters are sufficient to finish the task. We'll see how it goes real soon.



If you use the proper carbide cutter you can do the whole thing with it.
Regards,
Gerald
gibs035User is Offline
1st Class Member
Brakeman
Brakeman
Send Message
Posts:954
gibs035

--
27 May 2008 12:34 PM  
Howard,
The Goose "2 that I have is all metal. I have contacted the "Andrea" people to see what they can do for me. Thanks for your help and reply.
xo18thfaUser is Offline
1st Class Member
Foreman
Foreman
Send Message
Posts:1627
xo18thfa

--
27 May 2008 02:56 PM  
Howard: These fine castings are probably investment cast. HSS tools work well cutting thru the crust. It's the bigger castings done in sand molds that can cause trouble. You nick a piece of leftover sand and the tool edge is gone instantly. If you go with HSS tools the worst you will have to do is maybe resharpen when you are done.

Once upon a time I turned four cast iron wheels, 5 inch diameter, on a 6 inch Atlas, with HSS and they turned out well.

Yours will be beautiful.

Bob
Bob Sorenson
Las Vegas, Nevada
SA #13
"Goals are dreams with deadlines"
maculsayUser is Offline
1st Class Member
Brakeman
Brakeman
Send Message
Posts:320
maculsay

--
02 Jun 2008 11:16 AM  
I decided to add a 1/8" layer under the cab/hood/boiler to facilitate raising the deck beams to help clear the rear wheels. To kill 2-birds-with-1-stone, the layer is high heat circuit board material...hence an insulation layer between burner/boiler and the rest of the brass undercarriage. Additionally, the cab & hood will be connected together so that it'll lift off the undercarriage in one piece. At the front of this .015" thick brass base connector is a piece bent 90degrees vertical and shaped to fit the backside of the radiator casting. The white metal radiator casting will be epoxied to front of its vertical brass backing.

The next picture shows the insulation layer mounted to the brass undercarriage using three 2-56 screws which also attach the boiler. Each of the oak deck beams are attached to the 1/8" thick insulation layer by 2-56 NBWs. The deck's oak crossbeam is escutchion pinned and CA'd.

This picture shows the wood cab floor positioned to be attached to the brass cab/hood base connector along with the front hood support soldered to the backside of the vertical radiator backing.


I added more detail to the cab side drawing....showing the positioning of the rear hood support and a wire beading that will be added along the edge of the door openings. The hood supports are brass channel bent to approximate the shape of the radiator. The open side of the channel faces out so that a wire beading soldered to the hood's front & rear edges will fit into the channel.

And lastly, showing the rear hood support being readied for soldering to the cab's front wall. The opening for the front windscreen is yet to be cut using my nibbler.

Now I've got to stop & allocate some time getting ready for the Big Train Show. It's so hard to divey up my time between all these fun things. Last week it was a steamup, yesterday a one-day AT&SF3751 steam excursion run to San Diego and back....when will I get time to cut the lawn....Whoa is me<img src=" border=0>
Howard Maculsay SA #4450 My RailRoadRadio.net broadcast site
maculsayUser is Offline
1st Class Member
Brakeman
Brakeman
Send Message
Posts:320
maculsay

--
03 Jun 2008 05:34 PM  
Heck with cutting the lawn, this is more fun<img src=" border=0>
I finished cutting the cab sides and connected the cab with the hood/cab base connector by soldering it to the bottom of the rear hood support. Onto the inside of the cab's back wall I soldered a couple of L-shaped brass pieces to secure the cab to the wood floor and in-turn to the base connector using escutcheon pins. (In the first picture one of the escutcheon pins is shown pointing towards the L-shaped supports.) The pins will extend down into the insulation layer as part of the cab's positioning/fastening scheme. Another pin will be used to positon the front of the hood and a single 2-56 screw down through the the floorboard and threaded into the brass undercarriage will secure the whole cab assembly.
Across the inside of the cab's front, I added a reinforcing strip of brass to stiffen-up the top of the windscreen frame. Down each side of the windscreen, I added a length of 1/8" square brass tubing to form the 2 front posts.
The top of the cab sides needed some stiffening, so I added a rectangular brass piece near the top at the back. This also holds a short portion of the sides at right angles to the back wall before allowing the sides to curve in towards the narrower front wall. Wire beading will be soldered to the edges of the curved door openings.


The brass roof will be hand-shaped and a wire beading will be soldered to the underside of the 4 edges. Whether to make the roof hinged for easy access or to just remove the entire cab has not been decided.
I did a fit check to see if the clearances needed for the butane fuel cannister are intact and although very tight, they are as planned.

And I placed the cab/hood assembly into place on the under carriage and it's all fitting as planned.



More later!!! Now the lawn<img src=" border=0>.
Howard Maculsay SA #4450 My RailRoadRadio.net broadcast site
Tenn SteamUser is Offline
Passenger
Passenger
Send Message
Posts:39
Tenn Steam

--
04 Jun 2008 11:34 AM  
I always found the grass would still be waiting if I did something else before I got around to cutting it. When your car disappears in the grass, it is time to mow lawns, not before.
You are not authorized to post a reply.
Page 1 of 41234 > >>


Active Forums 4.2
Top of Page | Terms of Use | Copyright 2009 by myLargescale.com/Model Railroads Online, LLC  | Privacy | Contact Us